Blog

How to verify a tipster: a verified record instead of screenshots

A winning screenshot is easier to fake than to win. Here is how to check a tipster properly: what a verifier must record, which numbers to look at and how many bets it takes before a profit means anything.

How to verify a tipster: ask for a link to a verified betting record instead of screenshots — a record where every bet is stored before kickoff at the bookmaker's price, settled independently and impossible to delete. Then look at three things: how many bets the sample holds, what ROI comes at what average odds, and what the drawdowns looked like. Everything else is marketing.

Step by step below. Betting carries a risk of losing money, and even an honest record does not guarantee that a tipster keeps winning. It only separates what actually happened from what someone wants to show.

Why screenshots and spreadsheets prove nothing

A screenshot of a bet slip shows one bet the author picked. It does not show the losses that never made it to the channel, bets placed after kickoff, or slips built from a dozen variants. Editing an image is not hard either.

A spreadsheet in Excel or Google Sheets is better, but it has the same flaw: the tipster types everything in. The price can be the best one seen that day, a losing bet can be "forgotten", and a bad month can start over on a fresh sheet.

So how to check a tipster starts not with the numbers but with who recorded them. If the author of the picks keeps the record, there is nothing in it to check.

What verifying a tipster means

Verifying a tipster means keeping their bets with a third party that does not let anyone adjust the result. A good verifier records four things:

  • time — the bet is stored before kickoff, not after a goal;
  • price — the odds come from the bookmaker's line, not typed in by hand;
  • settling — the service decides the outcome from the score and the match stats, not the author;
  • completeness — a lost bet cannot be deleted, and a fresh start of the bank is visible.

That is how the xG.Football bet verifier works: the price comes from the line of the most senior bookmaker that offers the market (Pinnacle first, then Bet365 and others), bets are taken only before the whistle, the site settles them, and they can never be edited or deleted. A bank can be reset, but the number of resets is always shown on the public page.

Watch the resets. A service where a losing bank can be quietly deleted and a new one opened shows only the lucky attempts. It is the same collection of best screenshots, only as a table.

A tipster's betting record: which numbers to check

Sample size — how many bets

The first number to look at is not the profit but the count of settled bets. Twenty winning bets say almost nothing, a hundred say a little, several hundred allow careful conclusions. Why — in the next section.

ROI and average odds — together

ROI is the profit divided by the total staked. ROI +10% at average odds of 1.60 and ROI +10% at average odds of 4.00 are very different results: high odds spread much wider, and the same profit is easier to get by chance. Look at both numbers at once.

A hit rate without odds means nothing. Winning 70% of bets at odds around 1.30 is a loss; winning 40% at odds around 3.00 is a profit.

Drawdowns and streaks

An honest betting record always contains bad stretches. A bank chart without a single drawdown over a long run should worry you rather than please you. How long a normal losing streak gets at a given hit rate can be worked out with the losing streak calculator.

Pre-match bets at real prices

If a service lets you bet after kickoff or type the odds by hand, its record cannot be trusted: it will hold bets on things that already happened and prices that were never in the line.

How many bets before a profit means anything

Take a tipster with no edge at all: they bet on events with a 50% chance at odds of 2.00. Even with no bookmaker margin, in the most favourable conditions for them, their expected result is zero. Here is how often such a random bettor still shows ROI of +10% or more:

Bets in the sample Chance of ROI from +10% with no edge
100 18.4%
300 4.7%
1000 0.09%

Over a hundred bets, about one tipster in five who is effectively flipping a coin looks successful. A tipster betting at odds around 3.00 spreads even wider: over 100 bets, ROI from +10% happens by chance in about a quarter of cases, from +20% in nearly one case in ten. Over 1000 bets at the same odds, a random bettor reaches ROI from +10% in about 1.35% of cases.

The main conclusion: checking a tipster over a short run tells you almost nothing. More on how chance drives short-term results — in the article on betting variance.

There is a second effect. There are many tipsters, and the lucky ones are the ones you see in ads. If a hundred authors with no edge each place a hundred bets, about eighteen of them will show ROI from +10% — and those are the ones selling subscriptions.

Signs of a dishonest record

  • no drawdown at all over a long run;
  • you cannot see the bets of the whole period, only "the best month";
  • the record starts recently while the channel has been around for years;
  • the odds are higher than the line had for that match;
  • picks are posted after kickoff or as "closed" posts without a time;
  • the author keeps the record and gives no link to an independent service.

No single sign proves cheating, but several at once are a strong reason not to pay.

How to show your own record if you are a tipster

If you give picks yourself, the best argument for followers is the same check you would expect from others. In the xG.Football tracker you can keep your bets for free and turn on a public link to a bank. The page shows verified bets only: profit, ROI, hit rate, average odds, a bank chart, breakdowns by market and competition and the latest settled bets. Bets that have not been played yet show only as a count: your pick opens after the match, so nobody copies it for free.

The site's own model lives by the same rules: every pick is stored before kickoff and never changed after it, and the results are open in the prediction tracker.

Know the limits in advance: the verifier works with football only, with pre-match bets only and with matches the site has a line for. The bank is virtual — the site takes no real money.

Summary

Question Answer
How do I verify a tipster? Ask for a link to a verified betting record and look at the sample size, ROI together with the average odds, and the drawdowns.
How to check a tipster without screenshots? Use a verifier: a screenshot shows a bet the author picked and hides the losses, the time of the bet and the real price.
What does verifying a tipster mean? Keeping their bets with a third party: stored before the match at the line's price, settled by the service and impossible to delete.
How many bets does a tipster's record need? At least several hundred: over 100 bets at odds of 2.00, a bettor with no edge shows ROI from +10% in about 18% of cases.
What matters more — hit rate or ROI? ROI together with the average odds: a hit rate without odds says nothing about profit.

Plain-language guides on reading football stats and predictions: what xG actually measures, how to read shots-on-target and corner stats, how the xG.Football prediction model works, and what terms like "both teams to score" or "total" mean.

← Back to all blog articles

Match statistics